I've been mostly quiet in this thread, because I know that my opinion WILL be offensive to others, and I don't want to go there.
I will say this. Throughout this thread, the focus is on the WOMAN. Almost never did I read (though I'm only on page 17!) any comments about what's best for the CHILDREN. When it comes to motherhood, seems to me like that should be the primary concern.
I think the issue is the concept of best for the child -
Or that's what will be offensive, I suppose.
I'll start out with the offending.
I, personally, strongly feel that a child
deserves to have their
parent (not nanny, not gramma, not daycare worker - and I'm talking mama and/or daddy) providing a
majority of the hands-on care for that child. I think that, bottom line (assuming mama ain't abusive, of course) is the best option for the child - just for the breastmilk, if nothing else.
I disagree - strongly, vigorously, and sometimes rudely - with the concept of farming off parenthood to a hired employee who has no connection with that child besides the money they are being paid and any emotions they might build up while working with the child, and I'll fully admit (and accept) the fact that I piss people off by saying it.
And if 3/4 of your childs awake time is spent being taken care of, disciplined, taught, encouraged, soothed, fed, talked to, read to, etc by someone other than a parent -
erplexed - plenty of kids come out just FINE - I'm not saying any different - but I'm not sure if that is what's
best for the child.
Now (and here come the disclaimers) - I think that's the BEST situation. If having mama home means you don't have a roof over your head - well, that's different, obviously. If having mama home means she's popping valiums because she's so depressed - well, that might not be best.
And of course, every parent does, what they feel in their heart, is best for their child (or at least, one would hope). So I can't knock the mama's that feel like working outside of the house - by providing them some sense of 'being' or fulfilling some needs of theirs - allows them to be better mothers. Meh. I don't
agree, but it ain't my kid/life/family/household, either.
*waits for the rotten tomatoes*