You're getting good results because your method sorts for 'traditional men'. Your profile does a lot of the work for you. By using that word, 'beneficial', you exclude fckbois and men who want to go dutch. By not leading the conversation, you appear submissive. A hunter is more likely to be 'traditional', as is a man wearing a suit
with a genuine smile. The suit alone could go either way, but the genuine smile (instead of a too cool for school smirk or similar) tells you that he just wanted to put his best foot forward to a potential mate. That's old school. And he probably washes his legs, too.
Good job. This is a great case study of how to make SM work.