Do you think black men as a group are as loyal to black women as we are to them?

Lol, not trying to argue back and forth, but this essentially sums up what I was trying to say:
rejuvenation1: Sorry to jump in, but I am confused by your post. What you said was:
Black men MARRY out the least. White men MARRY out the most (to Asians, then Latin and other). Black men may look like they date/have sex outside of their race, but in terms of marriage, the vast majority are married to black women.
NikStar introduced stats that show your statement is incorrect and that black men marry out at rates higher than white men. How do the stats you introduced in your last post refute the stats showing that black men intermarry at higher rates than white men do?
 
@snilloh: Your argument is circular. It basically goes: The right kind of black woman is shown loyalty by black men. Thus, when a black woman is not shown loyalty by black men, it is because she is not the right kind of black woman. All of this relies on the idea that the right kind of black woman is shown loyalty by black men, which is something you have not proven or offered any evidence at all to support and have just blanketly stated. If it's just your opinion, that's fine, but as an argument, it is fallacious.

Thiends I definitely didn't post in hopes for agreement from...well anyone here! With that said, and perhaps to simplify, I think men view the "right kind of women", differently than women do.

I don't have enough time to show evidence, and didn't know I was required to do so? OP asked for opinions, and I gave mine. I didn't know we needed to submit per ca pita data to back up our opinions.
 
@Thiends I definitely didn't post in hopes for agreement from...well anyone here! With that said, and perhaps to simplify, I think men view the "right kind of women", differently than women do.

I don't have enough time to show evidence, and didn't know I was required to do so? OP asked for opinions, and I gave mine. I didn't know we needed to submit per ca pita data to back up our opinions.
@snilloh: A coherent explanation of what your opinion is based on would do just fine. "Black men are loyal to the right type of woman" followed by "black women who are not shown loyalty by black men are not the type of woman" isn't a coherent explanation. You're welcome to your opinion though!
 
I think men, in general, are loyal to the types of women they want. And men, in general, seem to want similar things (variations do exist across cultures, but the basic premise is the same).

:yep::yep::yep: Totally agree!!


How many of us are/or are willing to become "that"? Should we even want to/have to try?
This is where the feminist movement comes in. Those that think this way are affected by such movement, and more often than not are usually alone when they actually desire a black man. I am not saying this is right. Quite honestly it down right sucks, however I really believe this is today's reality regardless if anyone agrees with it or not.
 
@nagawa The types that walk the "tightrope" of have their stuff together while not entangled in the feminist movement. Its a fine line, and many black women are on either side of the rope. Not to many walk right in the middle. (waits for the defensive posts from other posters based on assumptions )

Concise and insightful analysis... I believe this to be true for most middle class black men.
 
No I don't think black men are as loyal to black women as black women are to them. Unfortunately, for BW many of the issues that are detrimental to us are issues that caused or compounded by the actions of BM. So of course they wouldn't be open to supporting BW in those issues.
 
@nagawa The types that walk the "tightrope" of have their stuff together while not entangled in the feminist movement. Its a fine line, and many black women are on either side of the rope. Not to many walk right in the middle. (waits for the defensive posts from other posters based on assumptions )

edited to add -- I think there are 3 types of black men.

The Coons -they will throw us under the bus at any given time.

The Soulbrothers - They generally try to support all black women.

The Uptight Brotha - This is the black man who thinks he is better than most, and is usually threatened by black women who are seemingly in the same position financially as he is...but will back down for certain types of black women. The above definition is in regards to the Uptight Brotha. The Uptight Brother will usually marry an "otheren" , but will settle down with the "right" (his definition of right) black women.

This is very interesting indeed. :yep: I wonder if most men can identify a feminist versus an ABW, and I daresay they probably can't. At any rate, otherwise your theory makes sense.
 
hellz naw .....

snilloh the soulbrother that professes to be pro-black has always been known to get with a white girl as they always just wanted a woman to cater to them and not fight for our rights cause at the end of the day we're women and they think their struggle is so much worse than ours.....i don't think its up for comparison,imo.:sad:
the uptight brother and coon can actually be the same person and he ends up marrying out as well whining that we were never there for them in their time of need and that we were too hard on them. or they could have such an intense self-hatred they marry suzy with the hope of diluting the gene pool.:nono:
 
Last edited:
If you have the right set of physical traits and personality, yes, bm are more likely to be loyal to you. If not, most likely not.
 
This is very interesting indeed. :yep: I wonder if most men can identify a feminist versus an ABW, and I daresay they probably can't. At any rate, otherwise your theory makes sense.

To be honest, I'm still confused as to what constitutes the "right" Black woman; however, I can simply say that, from my experience, men can most definitely differentiate between a feminist vs. an ABW. Mos def. :yep:

Can someone just come out and state, explicitly, what is meant in the notion that Black men are loyal to certain Black women? Raspberry and snilloh, you two seem to be of one accord in this regard, and I'd like to know more specifics for the sake of satisfying my own curiosity. Do you mean Black women that adhere to gendered roles of femininity? Black women who will "stay in their lane" - whatever that looks like? Black women with certain features? Please help a sista out.

Otherwise, to answer the OP, no. Just no.
 
hellz naw .....

@snilloh the soulbrother that professes to be pro-black has always been known to get with a white girl as they always just wanted a woman to cater to them and not fight for our rights cause at the end of the day we're women and they think their struggle is so much worse than ours.....i don't think its up for comparison,imo.:sad:
the uptight brother and coon can actually be the same person and he ends up marrying out as well whining that we were never there for them in their time of need and that we were too hard on them. or they could have such an intense self-hatred they marry suzy with the hope of diluting the gene pool.:nono:

:lol::lol:
 
hellz naw .....

snilloh the soulbrother that professes to be pro-black has always been known to get with a white girl as they always just wanted a woman to cater to them and not fight for our rights cause at the end of the day we're women and they think their struggle is so much worse than ours.....i don't think its up for comparison,imo.:sad:
the uptight brother and coon can actually be the same person and he ends up marrying out as well whining that we were never there for them in their time of need and that we were too hard on them. or they could have such an intense self-hatred they marry suzy with the hope of diluting the gene pool.:nono:

I totally, completely, and unreservedly agree with this. In my opinion what differentiates a soul brother from a coon from an uptight brother are the words they spout from their mouths when the time is right. Otherwise their actions tell the same tale across the board.
 
To be honest, I'm still confused as to what constitutes the "right" Black woman; however, I can simply say that, from my experience, men can most definitely differentiate between a feminist vs. an ABW. Mos def. :yep:

Wowzers, maybe its my generation, but some of them could not spot feminist ideal with a neon sign. Hell some women can't :lachen:
 
I totally, completely, and unreservedly agree with this. In my opinion what differentiates a soul brother from a coon from an uptight brother are the words they spout from their mouths when the time is right. Otherwise their actions tell the same tale across the board.

I think the only difference between them is how much money they have.
 
To be honest, I'm still confused as to what constitutes the "right" Black woman; however, I can simply say that, from my experience, men can most definitely differentiate between a feminist vs. an ABW. Mos def. :yep:

Can someone just come out and state, explicitly, what is meant in the notion that Black men are loyal to certain Black women? @Raspberry and @snilloh, you two seem to be of one accord in this regard, and I'd like to know more specifics for the sake of satisfying my own curiosity. Do you mean Black women that adhere to gendered roles of femininity? Black women who will "stay in their lane" - whatever that looks like? Black women with certain features? Please help a sista out.

Otherwise, to answer the OP, no. Just no.

I don't think it has anything to do with looks. Granted we can agree that a woman who is in shape, dresses nicely, keeps herself up..etc is desired by most men.

Looks aside, and using some of the words you posted---

I definitely think that black women who display femininity, while able to hold her own. Meaning, hold your own without trying to be a man.

A woman who "stays in her lane" by allowing the man to truly be the head of household. For lack of a better word, women who are able to submit without losing themselves.

That is why I said it is a very tight rope. Many black women are raised by their mother's only, and more often than not they see their mother's take on the role of head of household, and most are conditioned to adhere to this definition of what a woman should be (i.e. strong black woman). That mindset is usually a turn off for some black men which is why you catch those types of men throwing black women under the bus. However if they were able to meet a certain type, they will usually marry a black woman over a woman of a different race.

I realize I am probably rambling, and can explain further if need be. I just don't wanna burn up the chicken. :look:
 
Last edited:
I think the only difference between them is how much money they have.

ITA, I think a coon is a broke high-school drop out with no job who hangs out on the corner all day. The soul brother went to college or graduated college but is in a field that is prestigious but low paying like a teacher or social worker. The uptight brother graduated college and is in a well paying career or a high paying career.

I don't think all black men fall into these three "types" for instance I know a lot of black men who are great and support black women, but these types listed definitely exist.
 
I don't think it has anything to do with looks. Granted we can agree that a woman who is in shape, dresses nicely, keeps herself up..etc is desired by most men.

Looks aside, and using some of the words you posted---

I definitely think that black women who display femininity, while able to hold her own. Meaning, hold your own without trying to be a man.

A woman who "stays in her lane" by allowing the man to truly be the head of household. For lack of a better word, women who are able to submit without losing themselves.


That is why I said it is a very tight rope. Many black women are raised by their mother's only, and more often than not they see their mother's take on the role of head of household, and most are conditioned to adhere to this definition of what a woman should be (i.e. strong black woman). That mindset is usually a turn off for some black men which is why you catch those types of men throwing black women under the bus. However if they were able to meet a certain type, they will usually marry a black woman over a woman of a different race.

I realize I am probably rambling, and can explain further if need be. I just don't wanna burn up the chicken. :look:

I laughed out loud when I read the last bolded. :lol:

I see what you're saying (and no, you're not rambling). I suspected that this is what you meant but I wanted to be clear.

To be perfectly frank with you, in my observations of my married Black male friends, a lot of what you're saying, especially the bolded, rings true. :yep: It is indeed a challenging role to navigate (remaining strong and true to yourself while allowing a man to lead) but I remember someone saying something that really stood out to me: men would rather feel respected than feel loved. It's not to say that they don't want both, but I would think that the perception of respect would be all the more salient for Black men since we live in a society that strives to strip them of this fundamental quality day in, day out. Unfortunately, because of the prevalence of dysfunctional family dynamics in some Black families, many equate having a woman they can walk all over as someone who respects them. :nono: But now I'm the one rambling so I'll just stop. :lol:
 
I don't give a solid $hit because I am not loyal to them. I am loyal to those loyal to the cause whatever their ethnic make up may be. :peace:

It doesn't even upset me when I run into coons, I look at them like a science project and keep it moving. :giggle: I do feel sorry for the white/exotico chick they may be with or desire--because for some of those a$$holes it's just the womb, skin, and hair they want and once the kids come its either on to the next one or both are so blind to the self hatred that is the catalyst to the relationship that they both have effed up notions.
 
To be honest, I'm still confused as to what constitutes the "right" Black woman; however, I can simply say that, from my experience, men can most definitely differentiate between a feminist vs. an ABW. Mos def. :yep:

Can someone just come out and state, explicitly, what is meant in the notion that Black men are loyal to certain Black women? @Raspberry and @snilloh, you two seem to be of one accord in this regard, and I'd like to know more specifics for the sake of satisfying my own curiosity. Do you mean Black women that adhere to gendered roles of femininity? Black women who will "stay in their lane" - whatever that looks like? Black women with certain features? Please help a sista out.

To the bolded - definitely.

However, I'm trying to avoid defining a specific "right" kind of black women because that just gets us distracted by shallow caricatures of perfect women (something like Claire Huxtable with a dash of old school Foxy Brown) that these self proclaimed black relationship gurus are always harping on about.

I take snilloh's observations as more of a general rule - that most stable black men want a woman who is productive, responsible, and emotionally stable while holding to a fairly traditional view of male/female relationships. They want the world to be simple again. The goal post is pretty wide for those standards depending on the man in question IMO.
 
side-eye.gif
 
I know some black men don't think black women are loyal to them at all. That we always say black men ain't ish. "They triflin, irresponsible, arrested development good-for-nothings." Just like the guy who told the poster in another thread "you woulda talked to me if I was white." That black women would date out more if, well, to put it bluntly, if they could.

So I guess the question presumes something that not everyone accepts, namely that black women are loyal to black men in the first place.


Yes the entire thread topic is based on an assumption and "that black women are more loyal to black men than black men are loyal to black women." Naturally underlying that assumption would have to be the assumption that black women are loyal. Like any other assumption it is not necessarily based on fact, which is why I posed the question by saying some people. I am not sure how widely accepted this assumption is though I have come across it frequently.
 
Last edited:
I don't think it has anything to do with looks. Granted we can agree that a woman who is in shape, dresses nicely, keeps herself up..etc is desired by most men.

Looks aside, and using some of the words you posted---

I definitely think that black women who display femininity, while able to hold her own. Meaning, hold your own without trying to be a man.

A woman who "stays in her lane" by allowing the man to truly be the head of household. For lack of a better word, women who are able to submit without losing themselves.

That is why I said it is a very tight rope. Many black women are raised by their mother's only, and more often than not they see their mother's take on the role of head of household, and most are conditioned to adhere to this definition of what a woman should be (i.e. strong black woman). That mindset is usually a turn off for some black men which is why you catch those types of men throwing black women under the bus. However if they were able to meet a certain type, they will usually marry a black woman over a woman of a different race.

I realize I am probably rambling, and can explain further if need be. I just don't wanna burn up the chicken. :look:

Which is interesting considering how many black children (male and female) are raised in single parents households with many men describing their mothers as "strong black women." Hmnn, I guess they wouldn't want to marry mama huh?
 
I laughed out loud when I read the last bolded. :lol:

I see what you're saying (and no, you're not rambling). I suspected that this is what you meant but I wanted to be clear.

To be perfectly frank with you, in my observations of my married Black male friends, a lot of what you're saying, especially the bolded, rings true. :yep: It is indeed a challenging role to navigate (remaining strong and true to yourself while allowing a man to lead) but I remember someone saying something that really stood out to me: men would rather feel respected than feel loved. It's not to say that they don't want both, but I would think that the perception of respect would be all the more salient for Black men since we live in a society that strives to strip them of this fundamental quality day in, day out. Unfortunately, because of the prevalence of dysfunctional family dynamics in some Black families, many equate having a woman they can walk all over as someone who respects them. :nono: But now I'm the one rambling so I'll just stop. :lol:

Yet I've heard from many male cohorts that they respect a strong woman, albeit a feminine strong woman. I do think though that it's quite o.k. to want a partner who respects you. I for cannot deal with verbal/emotional/physical abuse of any sort. I think that some people might have a twisted view of what it means to respect though.
 
People are loyal according to their options and where their interest/attractions lie.
Based on the above statement, black men are generally not loyal to black women.

As stated previously, you cannot go hard on a white woman like black men go hard on us. White men will go to bat for white women like you won't believe and being romantically loyal is the LEAST of it.
 
***I apologise for the following essay:lol:***

I personally believe that If you reduce this to the sum of it's parts, it's a gender issue first, more so than a racial one (eventhough race absolutely affects it, too). Gender dichotomies are the strongest social constructs in history, IMO. It effects every other -ism, -ist, issue out there. Just look at how often comments degenerate to, "Well men love it!" on this very board, as though the endorsement of a man is the be all and end all that we should all aspire to achieve. If a male likes it, it must be good.

I strongly believe that a white/black/asian male will be loyal to another male of his racial group before anyone else. Men are taught (even by women, which burns my soul) that they are better/different/without faults. It may no longer be as explicit anymore, as the use of pseudo-sciences to explain their supposed superiority over us is hushed, but, the undercurrent remains strong. Just because nobody says "Women are inferior baby receptacles" out loud to much public acclaim, doesn't mean the behaviour isn't encouraged. It's the subtle and hidden things that spiral into a dangerous mentality.

It sounds fickle, but, read some YT comments from pre-teen and teenage boys; they spew foolish things about women, their "place" and supposed lack of admirable abilities/qualities. They may have been born in the 21st century, but they operate on an archaic mindset. Worthless Neanderthals.

Hierarchies exist within other hierarchies; a white male is loyal to a white male first, then, a white women. Intra-racial loyalty operates on gender lines, IMO.
If he must show loyalty to another race, it will be to his gender counterpart.

Now, if you hoist black people and their loyalty issues into an interracial comparison sphere (I'm not talking about dating alone), then personally, I believe that black males show less loyalty to black women in comparison to the reverse. I believe a black male will throw a black woman under the bus more readily than his white/asian counterpart will throw their women under the grinding wheels of said vehicle.
I say this as a woman with three older brothers that I love dearly. Sometimes, those brothers of mine will fix their mouths to say some downright stupid S%!& about black women though :nono:
I swear, some of these beasts raised in the west...
 
I don't know a "soul brotha" under the age of 50 :look: so erm, that don't even count for me. Black men don't care about us, we need to stop caring about them. Point blank.

SMH, I can't believe that I'm even responding. This is like a rhetorical question. We all know the answer to it (lol)
 
To the bolded - definitely.

However, I'm trying to avoid defining a specific "right" kind of black women because that just gets us distracted by shallow caricatures of perfect women (something like Claire Huxtable with a dash of old school Foxy Brown) that these self proclaimed black relationship gurus are always harping on about.

I take snilloh's observations as more of a general rule - that most stable black men want a woman who is productive, responsible, and emotionally stable while holding to a fairly traditional view of male/female relationships. They want the world to be simple again. The goal post is pretty wide for those standards depending on the man in question IMO.

Great post, Raspberry. I see what you're saying. I think that the realities of the world are hastening a change in gender roles in American society, and it appears to have posed quite a shock to men regardless of race. Your argument that "they want the world to be simple again" resonated with me in view of the thread that Pookaloo created re: what men really want from women. Sadly, it seems that a lot of men want to have their cake and eat it, too: they want women to adhere to their roles but have no desire to fulfill the roles typically ascribed to them.

A bit off topic, but for some reason the Proverbs 31 woman keeps running through my mind as I contemplate some of the posts in this thread. Am I the only one for whom that's the case? :perplexed I wonder what that's all about.

***I apologise for the following essay:lol:***

I personally believe that If you reduce this to the sum of it's parts, it's a gender issue first, more so than a racial one (eventhough race absolutely affects it, too). Gender dichotomies are the strongest social constructs in history, IMO. It effects every other -ism, -ist, issue out there. Just look at how often comments degenerate to, "Well men love it!" on this very board, as though the endorsement of a man is the be all and end all that we should all aspire to achieve. If a male likes it, it must be good.

I strongly believe that a white/black/asian male will be loyal to another male of his racial group before anyone else. Men are taught (even by women, which burns my soul) that they are better/different/without faults. It may no longer be as explicit anymore, as the use of pseudo-sciences to explain their supposed superiority over us is hushed, but, the undercurrent remains strong. Just because nobody says "Women are inferior baby receptacles" out loud to much public acclaim, doesn't mean the behaviour isn't encouraged. It's the subtle and hidden things that spiral into a dangerous mentality.

It sounds fickle, but, read some YT comments from pre-teen and teenage boys; they spew foolish things about women, their "place" and supposed lack of admirable abilities/qualities. They may have been born in the 21st century, but they operate on an archaic mindset. Worthless Neanderthals.

Hierarchies exist within other hierarchies; a white male is loyal to a white male first, then, a white women. Intra-racial loyalty operates on gender lines, IMO.
If he must show loyalty to another race, it will be to his gender counterpart.

Now, if you hoist black people and their loyalty issues into an interracial comparison sphere (I'm not talking about dating alone), then personally, I believe that black males show less loyalty to black women in comparison to the reverse. I believe a black male will throw a black woman under the bus more readily than his white/asian counterpart will throw their women under the grinding wheels of said vehicle.
I say this as a woman with three older brothers that I love dearly. Sometimes, those brothers of mine will fix their mouths to say some downright stupid S%!& about black women though :nono:
I swear, some of these beasts raised in the west...

:clap: :clap: I never thought of it this way; great post CosmicVisitor!!! :yep: :yep:
 
How are you going to tag me in this thread RachelRegina?? :lachen:

Almost all the men doing black woman bashing are men I wouldn't consider in the first place (Ray J, Slim Thug, and my fav Dennis Rodman:rolleyes:) so the feeling is pretty mutual.

I think black men are pretty loyal to black women, but I never see them defending quains nearly as much as black women defend Kangs. Personally, I appreciate that. I don't want to see a decent educated brotha defending a quain acting a fool on Maury no more than I want to see decent, educated sistas defending kangs who don't pay child support, beat the hell out of their girlfriends, or pissing on teenagers :look:.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top