hopeful
Well-Known Member
So are we talking about us doing the Queen's Code Course (http://queenscodecourse.com) that starts October 27th? Or reworking our current stuff on GoodReads? I'm confused.
So are we talking about us doing the Queen's Code Course (http://queenscodecourse.com) that starts October 27th? Or reworking our current stuff on GoodReads? I'm confused.
I hope we are talking about reworking the current stuff on GoodReads. The other course is $297. I think it is an excellent value if you can afford it but.. I really have confidence in the group here to be able to pull great things from the book at cost of $0.00
I thought we were talking about reworking our own format. But honestly, I checked out the website after I wrote my post above and now Im probably going to do the course with Alison
You're right about the blind leading the blind part. Alison's bookclub is probably THE best option available right now.I'd love to do the course with Alison but I doubt I'd be able to participate live. She's holding it at such a random time.
ETA: I'd love to see us do our own formal course, but it almost seems as if some of this would be a richer experience with a moderator who is trained and well-versed in the topic, or else it's a bit like the blind leading the blind. That's where the appeal of Alison's course comes in
I'd love to do the course with Alison but I doubt I'd be able to participate live. She's holding it at such a random time.
ETA: I'd love to see us do our own formal course, but it almost seems as if some of this would be a richer experience with a moderator who is trained and well-versed in the topic, or else it's a bit like the blind leading the blind. That's where the appeal of Alison's course comes in
You're right about the blind leading the blind part. Alison's bookclub is probably THE best option available right now.
I'd love to do the course with Alison but I doubt I'd be able to participate live. She's holding it at such a random time.
ETA: I'd love to see us do our own formal course, but it almost seems as if some of this would be a richer experience with a moderator who is trained and well-versed in the topic, or else it's a bit like the blind leading the blind. That's where the appeal of Alison's course comes in
The tapes will be available right after I believe. You don't have to listen to them live. I think the only thing you will miss is some of the interactive stuff ("Each session includes an hour of clarification and additional material from Alison, followed by a half-hour Q&A, when she’ll act as your encyclopedia of men and women") that follows but meh I'm not worried about that.
I agree and I don't agree with the blind leading the blind. I think as far as some of the "behind the scenes" stuff she's offering in her bookclub as well as just the in-depth on her research it would definitely be of a value to do her. However, I've been in other bookclubs and groups that were self-lead and it turned out pretty well. Plus the main benefit I see to reading this with the group here is that Allison doesn't mention any nuance of black men and black women. And I think that intersectionality is important.
To that end, I also think that those of us who are doing the one Allison is leading can try to bring the other questions to that group for all of our benefit and we can help clarify if a question comes up here that Allison has already answered.
I agree and I don't agree with the blind leading the blind. I think as far as some of the "behind the scenes" stuff she's offering in her bookclub as well as just the in-depth on her research it would definitely be of a value to do her. However, I've been in other bookclubs and groups that were self-lead and it turned out pretty well. Plus the main benefit I see to reading this with the group here is that Allison doesn't mention any nuance of black men and black women. And I think that intersectionality is important.
To that end, I also think that those of us who are doing the one Allison is leading can try to bring the other questions to that group for all of our benefit and we can help clarify if a question comes up here that Allison has already answered.
That would be helpful. Hmmm, I may have to consider this. I could listen to them that following weekend.
Even if we had a few people participate, it would probably make our discussions here richer b/c people could share additional insights.
-For me a chapter each week is ideal. If we did it bi-weekly, then it would take 4 months to get through it. Yep, 1 chapter/week is good.
-Weekends and/or evenings are good for me. Anytime after 7pm cst. Works for me.
-I don't want to lead any discussions. I'm willing to give it a shot if no one else wants to do it. Maybe we could rotate?
-I don't think there should be a max number. Once you're in the club, you should be in it for life and be able to participate in the discussions whenever you see fit. This is one of those books where I'll have to reread and reread over and over again to make sure it becomes a part of who I am and that may take several iterations of going over the book and participating in live discussions. Now we may want to implement a max number of participants for the live calls due to costs and making sure people get the attention they need. I don't think she meant a maximum number indefinitely; just a manageable number for each cycle. Is that what you meant @Kimbosheart ? Because I don't plan on leaving- ever!
-I'd say reading the book once through should be recommended but not a requirement as we still have profound insights from just reading it once. Yep
I agree and I don't agree with the blind leading the blind. I think as far as some of the "behind the scenes" stuff she's offering in her bookclub as well as just the in-depth on her research it would definitely be of a value to do her. However, I've been in other bookclubs and groups that were self-lead and it turned out pretty well. Plus the main benefit I see to reading this with the group here is that Allison doesn't mention any nuance of black men and black women. And I think that intersectionality is important.
That would be VERY useful, especially for the women that can't do the course right now.To that end, I also think that those of us who are doing the one Allison is leading can try to bring the other questions to that group for all of our benefit and we can help clarify if a question comes up here that Allison has already answered.
Completely agree re the nuanced black men and women issue. I think the problem is the leading part. The lessons are so deep and complex. Like we can learn from each other, share, discuss, support, etc. But not sure any of us could lead but idk. I don't really do book clubs. We are all just learning and trying our best to implement. Our group could probably lead someone in 6 months maybe? Or in a year?
Yes I do think that those of us who do her course can provide additional insight.
My answers in red
This. I don't think it's like the blind leading the blind at all. I've also been in bookclubs and while I would've loved for Toni Morrison to come and explain parts of her book, I think we did okay by ourselves. They're not mutually exclusive paths and I'd hate to see everything brought to a halt because some ladies can't - or don't want to - buy the course. I also believe it would be beneficial for us to speak from our personal experiences as BW since our experiences are often very different from others' experiences.
That would be VERY useful, especially for the women that can't do the course right now.
That said, can we agree on a cut-off date to for people to "sign up"? How about 10/3 by midnight and we can officially start on 10/4 Sunday? The Goodreads board can stay as is, but we can start a new "Week 1 - 10/4-10-11 (or whatever we decide)" thread where we can put only questions pertaining to the book. The other week 1 thread can be used for personal stories/observations. That way questions from the "official" thread can be used as discussion points for the group call.
aarrgh how do you do the multiquote thing?
But @hopeful I think it's less "leading" and more moderating. Keeping the discussion on topic and making sure all opinions and questions can be aired. Perhaps also starting the calls off before we get into the discussions. I was also hoping that you would volunteer to help moderate. We have women in so many stages of life reading this book now. You've been married for awhile and have a daughter and I would love to hear from you and how you relate to this information from those perspectives. It's as valuable as the newlywed, in a serious relationship, single and looking, etc... Because of where we are in life we all connect with this information in a slightly different way.
...
You're right about the blind leading the blind part. Alison's bookclub is probably THE best option available right now.
Very nice @almond eyes. Thanks for sharing those observations.
I was watching Blackish and they had a seen where the wife was giving him the silent treatment and withholding sex and it all seemed very normal. If I hadn't read the book I wouldn't have questioned her tactics at all.