So why can't these be reasons for not attracting a man regardless of size? I am not talking about fat here, but for as the Op mentioned, for thick girls(and even for a person who is fat).
I am a skinny girl and I can say from experience, many times my thicker friends were picked over me. ALOT of men loved their size and most of all they were VERY comfortable in their skin. Thats why I think this argument is slightly moot. While women LOVED my shape, I found some men liked it and others thought I was on the thin side. So it depends. But I will say, this is a board of women and not many men post here, so I am always hesitant of hearing from women what men like
. And for the record, Dh has always prefered me bit thicker
.