The Scripture I posted was at the request of Lucia and I posted all the translations for THAT Scripture. Of course, I knew the article was about Catholics when I posted it - those are two different things because that Scripture applies to all. I don't know much about the author but I believe most of what the article said, which is why I posted it in the first place. Much like Catholics do not believe what Seven Day Adventists and charismatics and other denominations believe, Christians from those denominations also have a right to post their beliefs on this board without any backlash.
This isn't about any one person so I won't take it personally. Not all Christians are Catholics and not all Catholics consider themselves Christian. Because no one says anything when Catholics bash other denominations doesn't mean what's been going on is right.
For the record - I do not believe the Catholic Church as it is today is the Church - the Body of Christ includes anyone who accepts Jesus as their Lord and Savior, period. If they are not Catholic, that does not mean they are not a part of the True Church. This is something that has been repeated on here without regard to other Christians who visit the CF. I'm not afraid to speak up on this because that is what I believe.
When you post an article with no scripture to back it and that article basically trashes the entire faith with falsehoods, fabrications and heresey, you have to expect a response. Responding is not automatically backlash because it disagrees with your beliefs.
If you had questions or doubts or even curiousity about about the faith you could have posted things a different way not complete assertions based in misconceptions and falsehoods and then hide behind freedom of speech.
People have the right to express their beliefs that's true but does it have to be done in such an inflammatory and provoking nature? No, I think this could have been presented in a different tone if you wanted a true dialogue even spirited debate. You could have said I read this article and I was raised, taught, or just come to believe to be true.
Can any Catholics on here tell me if any part or all of this is true ? It just seems like you didn't even bother to speak to a Catholic or check any Catholic sources beforehand.
People forget that when you express your thoughts, others also have that
same right to express their thoughts on what you have said. Freedom of speech should be done responsibly.
You have a right to your beliefs but if you're beliefs about Catholics are based on falsehoods and outright lies we also have a right to correct falsehoods and heresy about the Catholic Church especially if you're leading other people to believe the same.
If we believe you're in error we must admonish as the bible says. It's not an attack to correct and admonish when necessary.
You basically called us out with a hodgepodge of different pagan beliefs and ascribed them to Catholicism with no scriptural or historical references that concretely link them just similarities, conjecture, accusations. Just cause paganism existed at that time then doesn't mean it was necessarily part of the Church that's like saying paganism is part of all Christian churches now just because they existed at the same time in the same place. Are there Christians who also practice paganism yes but that's the individual not the institution and they would be admonished for that and be told to confess and repent of it cause it's incompatible, you cannot have two masters, the same as in Roman times.
ETA: There were temples and worshippers of baal and molech in ancient Jewish times before Christ and during does that automatically link the early Jews to those pagan practices which also had similarities like burning offerings to their god? No the Jewish faith was different as they worshipped the one true God. That's also in the Bible Book of Ruth.
There is what people think they know about the Catholic Faith and Church and what the Catholic Faith and Church really is. Those are 2 very different things.
Just because we state the foundations of the early Christians and affirm that Catholicism is a direct lineage of that doesn't mean we totally reject all Protestants. Again that's an "assumption" you have made. What we believe is that our Protestant brothers and sisters are not in full communion with the Catholic Church. That's based on how different denominations pick certain sacraments to uphold and rejected the rest some denominations have no sacraments at all not even baptism also the books of the Bible, their interpretation, doctrine, Eucharistic presence of Christ vs just being symbolic, rosary, Marian veneration, authority, traditions of men vs traditions of God among other differences.
That's not bashing its a fact that the Reformation Fathers turned away from the Catholic Church. Luther was given many chances to recant after writing his 95 Theses but in the end he rejected all corrections and admonishments and was excommunicated from the Church.
It's also not bashing for me to state that Protestatism came out of Catholicism because that is the
truth. And if you're refuting Catholicism it logically follows you're refuting Protestants early roots and Protestanism itself. It's like Christians saying we didn't come out of Judaism that wouldn't make any sense cause that's illogical. Jesus and the Apostles were all Jews before being baptized in Christ.
I really pray that you will dig deeper and do your due diligence and some homework especially the history, origins and doctrines regarding your own denomination first and then get some basic information on different denominations within Christianity and not take some article, book, pastor or lay speaker at face value. And I hope your research leads you to the truth.
Show me in the Bible where it says you must accept Jesus Christ as your
personal Lord and Saviour?
Also when has any Catholic on the CF called Protestants out on the carpet in a way that was not charitable?
Resources
NABRE Bible, Ignatius Bible, RSV Bible or
Bible with apocrypha
Catechism of the Catholic Church or Boston or Penny Catechism
Luther 95 Theses
http://www.luther.de/en/95thesen.html
The Apostasy that wasn't
http://www.amazon.com/gp/aw/d/1941663494/ref=pd_aw_fbt_14_img_3?ie=UTF8&refRID=1FHJZWYX3DJ50NRM2KWG
The Protestants Dilemma
http://www.amazon.com/The-Protestants-Dilemma-Reformations-Consequences/dp/1938983610
Pope Fiction
http://www.amazon.com/Pope-Fiction-Answers-Misconceptions-Papacy/dp/0964261006