I believe that Shikakai is a saponid just like Aritha powder is, and Aritha definitely creates suds. I did a search on Shikakai, and it is a natural cleanser. I believe it's supposed to suds, but I could be wrong.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shikakai
Thanks Muffin! That would explain it. It also said this: Usually no rinse or conditioner is used since shikakai also acts as a detangler.
From what I have read about other people's experiences this stuff actually causes tangles. My hair didn't feel tangled after using this poo but it certainly wasn't detangled enough to go without conditioner.

Thanks Muffin!!:blowkiss:
So the conclusion for smoother rinsing (for me anyway) less powder, more liquid (HOT) then add cond.
Now tell me about this Fenugreek & oil on the stove?? Do you use other herbs??
.
Aggie, girl you are about to have me experimenting....... Tomorrow is my day off and I have some oils I would like to use up. I know my dd is gonna say what are you up to now.
Anyhoo I'll let you know how it turns out. How long do you usually store it before it goes bad?
This was a def. nono for me. My hair wasn't hard, but it was like all the other conds./ powders saved my hair from being a brittle mess. I wasn't the usual butter soft I'm used to after a treatment. Also I've found out I can on use about a 1/2 teaspoon of Shikakai in my mix. It's very drying to my hair, so I have to use it in super small doses. Another thing I noticed my hair isn't as soft when I add Amla, because it is acidic. I use this in moderation as well. Maybe you need to tweak your recipe. Also I never prepoo overnight and I still have great results. Right now I'm currently in love with the Shikakai bar.