There are many who do what they want to and make every excuse under the sun to do it. I am the exact same way, ...
Does God really agree with this. (I went to Mass and I raised my girls in catholic school) This is not to assault or offend you, this is what I did.
For instance, most churches have an altar, SDA churches do not. but they do call everyone up to the front they do not say Altar but in my mind its the same thing. I do not like that. I can't find a bible reason for us to do it. Because it appears as if you get extra attention because you go to the altar when you do not. But I learned this because I searched for an answer and then I sent a emails to a bible scholar to show me where I can find the real answers that I was missing and he confirmed what I already knew.
I am not trying to offend anyone but people are going to get offended regardless honestly there is nothing that can be done about that. Jesus did not drink fermented Wine, no matter how much folks want to believe he did, so they can drink it, he never did. Not ever. Because Jesus is the word made flesh,
There is One God, One Faith, and One Baptism. So we know that there are many, many faiths out there. Me personally, I want to follow the scriptures completely because it says one faith. The bible is our only standard, and we should all be on the same page, but as Christians we are not and the main reason why is folks want to do it their own way. Doesn't matter if this is what your churches teaches or not. The church is full of sinners and saints together. Can't follow them we have to follow Christ and thereby knowing and believing what the bible says is true.
I am also glad to see a fellow SDA on fire for the Lord. But I feel that I need to make a few corrections in some of the responses you have given in this thread are not an accurate account of SDA beliefs. First off we do have alters and alter calls in the SDA church. It has nothing to do with seeking attention and it has a biblical foundation. Also, the SDA church recently admitted that the wine drunk in biblical times was fermented. While there are many legitimate and biblical reasons that support a person's decision to abstain, we cannot re-write history because it supports our church views. I feel the need to point these things out because there are many here who are unfamiliar with SDA dogma and beliefs. And while your opinions are held by some in the church I want those reading this thread to also understand that some of your beliefs are personal and held by many in the denomination but are not the official position of our church. Lastly, I just wanted to state that agree with you on the fact that the bible should be our only guide. I hope that you continue to be blessed in you endeavor to draw close to God and be all that he would have you be. Be Blessed!
OK, now you are creating your own interpretation.
Yes so there are scriptures that indicate Jesus drank wine, but not directly saying so. Ok thanks.
Calling Him a drunkard or winebibber is pretty direct. And both translations say he came drinking...
Luke 7:33-35 (King James Version)
For John the Baptist came neither eating bread nor drinking wine; and ye say, He hath a devil. The Son of man is come eating and drinking; and ye say, Behold a gluttonous man, and a winebibber, a friend of publicans and sinners! But wisdom is justified of all her children.
For John the Baptist has come eating no bread and drinking no wine, and you say, ‘He has a demon. ’ The Son of Man has come eating and drinking, and you say, ‘Look at him! A glutton and a drunkard, a friend of tax collectors and sinners! ’ Yet wisdom is justified by all her children.”
Jesus was accused of a few things that he didn't do. We can assume he drank wine, fermented at that, but it only says drinking.
Also does wine promote holiness? Being sober minded? Idk
No assumption for me. I only go by the Word, which says He was called a drunkard/winebibber because unlike John who didn't eat bread or drink wine, Jesus came doing both. He came both eating and drinking.
It's very plain. Paul says wine help infirmities so yes to a degree it can promote holiness. Drinking wine doesn't mean you're not sober minded. Paul said a little. There is no specification as to how much Jesus drank, however, no where do I read he got drunk. He was called a drunkard because He drank wine, for all I know he had a sip or two and that was it. I have no clue the quantity.
What I do know is that drinking excess wine is strongly cautioned against. Becoming addicted to wine is forbidden. Over indulgence is considered sin. I'm sorry I can't look up scripture right now but it is strongly cautioned against drinking too much.
But to say it is sin to drink at all is the same as saying married people are not to have sex because it is sin. Sex is only forbidden outside of marriage to the one you are having relations with. So as long as the man and woman are married it is both ordained and commanded.
My point is that like there are guidelines with sex, there are guidelines with drinking wine. And one of those is not to drink with the brother or sister who is against it because that is a stumbling block for them.
blazingthru If your background is Catholic you probably are overlooking the alter in a SDA church. Most churches I attend have a simple wooden table in the front with an inscription and something resembling handles on the side. They usually have flowers or a runner on them. That is actually our alter. That is why people are invited to come down front-to where the alter is. We don't stress it but that is what it is. Our communion is placed on the alter and some churches leave the tithes and offerings on the alter. I have even seen members kneel before the alter during prayer. During the 90's alter calls were common at our church however they did become controversial when alter calls ended up being used for spiritual blackmail and putting people on the spot. So now people are invited to come up front, but us old school SDA still know that what is up front and where people are gathering is before the alter.
I wanted to clear up my statement on alcohol. The SDA church never changed their view on using alcohol. What they did address was the mounting evidence that new wine was fermented in some form. Even with that admission there is enough biblical evidence to make a strong argument against alcohol consumption. But as I said before, any church must be careful not to bend the truth to fit their understanding of the bible. We are to be sober minded and watching for the coming of the Lord. That is a lot easier to do when you are not intoxicated.
As for caffeine, that is a hot topic in our church. It boils down to whether the member believes EGW was speaking in absolutes or about abuse. There is also the fact that there are SDA who do not adhere to EGW's writings. And because unlike alcohol the bible is completely silent on caffeine it is up to our personal convictions to guide us in this area.
You say you attended Mass, but were you catholic? Anybody can go to catholic school but not all students can take the eucharist. Not all students are enrolled in the catechism studies. I would assume that you didn't have a deep knowledge of why and how and if G-d approved? That might be one reason it seemed so wrong for you.
I would say that you need to know the Jewish roots of your faith in order to put things into perspective. And those studies can last a lifetime to truly get the proper perspective. For me, the New Testament often doesn't make sense so I'm trying to come at it from the other direction, like, where on earth did they get this? I need and am seeking deep study in both. No, take that back, I am receiving because I'm discounting a group of wonderful people elsewhere who are guiding me in that. I guess they can count as "studies."
I need to think about this before I type it. I've already jacked up once today ...oh L-rd...but I'm going to say that, in your perspective that it is wrong and never happened when we've also learned that it is preference of several in the SDA and not their official teaching, the feeling of insult derives from your feeling that another is not walking the right path. Again, I'd point to learning the true Jewish roots of your faith and not just dietary laws but the reasons behind them and other laws to get a better understanding. Thing is, so many in CF do not believe other writings are necessary. This is how catholics and Jews differ (other than Jesus as Messiah) from you in that we have the sacred oral laws and their explanation in addition to scripture. It's kinda like "what came first, chicken or egg?"
This is where I take offense. There are scriptures demonstrating that Jesus drank wine....WINE, not grapejuice. He encouraged others to drink WINE. Now, as has clearly been displayed, those scriptures you posted and even agreed with are speaking on drunkenness. That is not equated with drinking wine, it's equated with drinking too much wine to become intoxicated.
People should say, "oh, my understanding is XYZ and what about ABC scriptures? Because my church encourages MNO" and never these pot shots of "well, I follow the L-rd and you don't." Why is that??? You know G-d and no one else does? Granted, some christians hate liquor, wine, dancing and cigarettes. That's fine. But when you cross the line to tell another person they are g-dless because they don't view it the way you do...uh, well.
If we approach this passage relying on the whole of Scripture, we must surely come to the conclusion that Jesus made unfermented wine
Eh???.........
Chile.....Eh???.........
Here I explain my feelings you read more into it then I intended. We serve the Lord doesn't mean no one else does, an any case, If God says wine is a mocker thats it. Leave it alone. But if you choose to drink it then that is your choice, we all have free will.
not offended at all. I use to be a social drinker but once I read the scriptures i gave it up. Its no longer a part of my life. Especially when I sit back later and wonder if I said to much or gave something away I should not have, that was to much for me. It was an easy thing to do. I actually don't think its misinterpreted I think honesty that people are going to drink regardless. "There's nothing wrong with a glass every now and then" who says that? the folks say that, Yet God say avoid it. who is right. Oh and by the way, The word "abomination" in the Bible symbolizes lies (Proverbs 12:22). Babylon's wine, which contains false teachings, disorients and benumbs those who drink it and makes them spiritually drunk.
... Most "Christian" feel that its okay to have a drink every now and then, yet God says do not even touch it because it will put you off guard and for some folks all they need is one drink, that's it.
...
Amnon, another drinker and the son of David, raped his half-sister Tamar. Because of this insidious act, he lost his life at the hands of his enraged brother while intoxicated (2 Samuel 13:28).
These are only a few examples. Truly, when one considers the biblical record of fermented drink, you have to wonder why any genuine Christian would argue in its defense!
.....
Also consider that there is an almost endless selection of other good things to drink that nourishes the body and mind. So why would any Christians want to gamble like this-risking their health, witness, family, and eternal life to argue in defense of this destructive substance? A very safe and simple rule for these issues is: When in doubt, leave it out!
As for me and my house we serve the Lord, so for me when I read the dangers of drinking from the word that is it for me. Since I choose to walk on the side that is going to keep me focus and on track. I will abstain, we all have free will to make our own choices, but fully knowing what the end results for so many, I don't see how a "christian" can drink calmly. But that is my opinion not an opinion from the word.
so that we can understand prophecy and the end times events that are going on now. Remember almost the entire world is deceived. the bible says over and over to be wise,
........ But you can't have this attitude to the word of God. Its no longer God your following but yourself, and thereby the door is opened wide for you to be fooled. Many are already blinded to what is going on right in front of their faces, for lack of wisdom.
There are many who do what they want to and make every excuse under the sun to do it. I am the exact same way, but its a thought I wrestle with, then I let it go because I have decided that I will follow the Bible and not pick and chose what I will take out of it or leave in it. If you feel that I was saying your Godless, well I don't know what to say. Your faith practices drinking wine, you do that in your services. If I was you, I would be thinking about it. Calling it into question. Does God really agree with this. (I went to Mass and I raised my girls in catholic school) This is not to assault or offend you, this is what I did. .....
I am not trying to offend anyone but people are going to get offended regardless honestly there is nothing that can be done about that. Jesus did not drink fermented Wine, no matter how much folks want to believe he did, so they can drink it, he never did. Not ever. Because Jesus is the word made flesh, why would he tell us to avoid it and then he drink it, that is false. So many folks accept the false teachings of Jesus without question, yet you want to call him your friend, really. ...The church is full of sinners and saints together. Can't follow them we have to follow Christ and thereby knowing and believing what the bible says is true.
.... I found it extremely boring, I was a child. I went when my friend got married she was catholic again, boring boring boring. I was like why. But I liked everything else we did in those days the Nuns were all over the place.....When I was pregnant with my son the Nuns helped me finish school and get my life together. They even allowed me to live with them. So I have nothing bad to say about those people they were good and kind.
The whole of Scripture is clearly and adamantly against the consumption of alcohol, but human nature will look upon any textual ambiguity as a “loophole” to justify drinking alcohol.
.
I Love my Church and my faith, but its my personal relationship with God is what will save me. Doesn't matter what church you belong too, well God says it does he says : “And I heard another voice from heaven saying, ‘Come out of her, my people, lest you share in her sins, and lest you receive of her plagues’ ” (Revelation 18:4).
in Bible prophecy. She, Her a Woman is a Church. please do not think this is the future this is now. Right now.
.......
Your also right, most Christians only want the scriptures and that is me............ because some of these folk refuse to believe anything, these same folks are talking about the exact same thing we already rehashed again and again. all the information was provided for study and yet they ask the same question again. they are Ever learning, and never able to come to the knowledge of the truth2 Timothy 3:7.
Not a heaven or hell issue...thank God!
But I think we can all agree that refraining from drunkeness is DEFINATELY prohibited. Everything else (to me) falls under cultural and individual preference and limits.
But I do caution us to remain apart from the world. Sitting at a bar with a beer isnt a good look for a Christian (in America). It will affect our witness to others. We must be careful of what we present to the world and to new CHristians who may not understand or be weak in their faith. But this goes for a lot of things that may not be sins in and of themselves.
If its wrong to you...please dont do it. If its wrong to your sister...please dont do it around her.
Oh and as for me...I absolutely HATE the taste of alcohol. Even the smell is gross to me. I'ev only had one kind of champagne that I found pleasant. My first taste of alcohol was in church lol. In undergrad when I was too tired to walk to the church I usually went to, I would go to the one on campus. It was presbetyrian I think. Well it happened to be communion sunday and i went up. Imagine my surprise when I dont taste welches grape juice in the cup!!! lol.
I am also glad to see a fellow SDA on fire for the Lord. But I feel that I need to make a few corrections in some of the responses you have given in this thread are not an accurate account of SDA beliefs. First off we do have alters and alter calls in the SDA church. It has nothing to do with seeking attention and it has a biblical foundation. Also, the SDA church recently admitted that the wine drunk in biblical times was fermented. While there are many legitimate and biblical reasons that support a person's decision to abstain, we cannot re-write history because it supports our church views. I feel the need to point these things out because there are many here who are unfamiliar with SDA dogma and beliefs. And while your opinions are held by some in the church I want those reading this thread to also understand that some of your beliefs are personal and held by many in the denomination but are not the official position of our church. Lastly, I just wanted to state that agree with you on the fact that the bible should be our only guide. I hope that you continue to be blessed in you endeavor to draw close to God and be all that he would have you be. Be Blessed!
Jesus was an obedient Jew. People hardly ever get that. Just because he told his disciples to pick and eat wheat on Shabbat doesn't mean He regularly disregarded Shabbat. He demonstrated that as Creator, He was the L-rd of Shabbat. The kiddusha is made over wine, always has been. Shrugs.