I love the goddess curls gelle. However, I like the Camille rose curl maker better than the goddess curls. They both work the same, but I get more use out of the Camille rose curl maker and my wng's last longer. The goddess curls has a stronger hold than the Camille rose. The goddess curls works AMAZING on twistouts!!!! It makes them VERY defined and last a lot longer. I actually prefer to use goddess curls for my twistouts than any other product.
I can see why Camille rose curl maker has mixed reviews. When I 1st used the product, I applied way too much and it left me with a VERY sticky transparent residue. Now I use very little of the product and have AWESOME results (pic in avatar, when hair is wet). Less is more with Camille rose. It still leaves me with alittle stickiness but not as bad when I 1st used the product.
ETA: I forgot to mention... IMO, I feel like the goddess curls is better for my scalp than the Camille rose curl maker. However, I prefer the results of the Camille rose than goddess curls; in regards to wng's. The Camille rose itches my scalp but it's not unbearable. I feel like with the Camille rose I def have to be more watchful for clogged pores.