If you don't want to use NTM and you want something creamy from the store, you might want to try Organics Leave-In Liquid Hair Mayonnaise, Jamaican Mango and Lime Cactus Leave-In, or Cantu Shea Leave In. I haven't used the last one but it looks decent.
The Cactus Leave-In has a non smell, it's sort of thick, but you can mix it with their itch growth spray (which has a nice scent OR a bit of their hair oil).
All of these items are at Walmart, but I'm sure you can find them at Walgreens, CVS, RITEAID, etc.
I prefer some natural stuff from online, or stuff I make myself but I definitely understand the urge to just walk in somewhere real quick and leave with what you need. I did it yesterday while at Wallyworld.
p1