• ⏰ Welcome, Guest! You are viewing only 2 out of 27 total forums. Register today to view more, then Subscribe to view all forums, submit posts, reply to posts, create new threads, view photos, access private messages, change your avatar, create a photo album, customize your profile, and possibly be selected as our next Feature of the Month.

Joico vs Redken

⏳ Limited Access:

Register today to view all forum posts.

Register Log in

Which is the best for soft moisturized hair

  • Joico

    Votes: 49 68.1%

  • Redken

    Votes: 15 20.8%

  • Other

    Votes: 8 11.1%
  • Total voters
    72
i use products from both interchangeably. i'm in the process of phasing out the tons of cheapie products my PJ-ism made me buy, and sticking to these two lines.

i enjoy redken's all soft conditioner, extreme conditioner, and smooth down butter treat. they all smell REALLY good. all soft is my favorite... it smells SOOOOO yummy... i use a little bit as a leave-in, just for the smell.
and i also love joico's kpak line, and the moisture recovery and silk result conditioner.

i don't use the shampoo from either line, because of the sulfates, so i couldn't tell you how that rates. hopefully someone can chip in :yep:
 
poookie said:
i use products from both interchangeably. i'm in the process of phasing out the tons of cheapie products my PJ-ism made me buy, and sticking to these two lines.

i enjoy redken's all soft conditioner, extreme conditioner, and smooth down butter treat. they all smell REALLY good. all soft is my favorite... it smells SOOOOO yummy... i use a little bit as a leave-in, just for the smell.
and i also love joico's kpak line, and the moisture recovery and silk result conditioner.

i don't use the shampoo from either line, because of the sulfates, so i couldn't tell you how that rates. hopefully someone can chip in :yep:
Click to expand...
ITA.....................
 
i think redken is better. joico wasnt anything special to me. i love redken all soft line, the heavy cream, shampoo and conditioner.
 
JOICO!!!!! K-Pak to be exact!
My hair, which is very thick and course absoutely:lick::lick::lick:LOVES it!!!

I tried Redken's Butter Treat because it was recommended, but did not experience anywhere near the type of slip that I get from the K-Pak.
I'm finding that you really have to discover what works for you.:yep:

HTH
 
normacyri said:
I tried Redken's Butter Treat because it was recommended, but did not experience anywhere near the type of slip that I get from the K-Pak.
I'm finding that you really have to discover what works for you.:yep:
Click to expand...

Yeah, I bought samples of the Smooth Down con, poo, & butter treat last night (2.95ea at ULTA) and tried them out today. It dried my hair out :ohwell:, me no likey :nono:. I'm just glad I didn't get the full-sized bottles.

I shall not stray from Kenra again, and yes it's absolutely about finding what works for you.
 
Joico...hands down :kneel:! This is the ONLY SALON product line I use ( i stick to mainly natural ingredients). It has made a tremendous difference in the strength and resiliency of my hair. The K-pak line (w/ shampoo) and moisture recovery conditioners are what I use exclusively.
 
Last edited:
queen_t said:
Yeah, I bought samples of the Smooth Down con, poo, & butter treat last night (2.95ea at ULTA) and tried them out today. It dried my hair out :ohwell:, me no likey :nono:. I'm just glad I didn't get the full-sized bottles.

I shall not stray from Kenra again, and yes it's absolutely about finding what works for you.
Click to expand...

I did this today:yep:. It was wonderful on my hair. It has a lot of body and shine and movement. I haven't tried Joico, but I don't think I need to after this. If I can find some samples I might, but I doubt it.
 
Redken hands down. I really like the All Soft conditioner and I love, love love the Real Control line (both the shampoo and the conditioner). Everytime I use it (it's been about 6 weeks now) my hair feels and looks better (soft, shiny and strong). I'm about 16 or 17 weeks post and will probably go to 20 or more thanks to Redken Real Control.

I tried Joico Moisture Recovery line (shampoo and conditioner) earlier this year and experienced nothing special and it was a major pain trying to squeeze the product out of the container:perplexed.

I'm a Redken devotee!
 
Last edited:
Joico all the way! Luuuuuvs the Moisture recovery line! So much slip, and soft detagled hair is what's up!
 
i change my vote!!! i'm going steady with the Joico Silk Result Line. I washed, blow-dried, conditioned last night== and my hair STILL feels bouncy and fluffy. Redken can NOT compare to this line (though the Smooth Down Butter Treat is an EXCELLENT leave-in)

:goes on EBay to buy the gallon sizes of both:
 
poookie said:
i change my vote!!! i'm going steady with the Joico Silk Result Line. I washed, blow-dried, conditioned last night== and my hair STILL feels bouncy and fluffy. Redken can NOT compare to this line (though the Smooth Down Butter Treat is an EXCELLENT leave-in)

:goes on EBay to buy the gallon sizes of both:
Click to expand...

Is this a new line? :look:
 
I Just started using Joico and the Moisture Recovery line left my hair feeling like butter! I left the mask on for longer than 5 minutes but my hair felt good after just the conditioner. Really left my hair detangled, although I did use the leave in detangler from the Daily Care line. I have products from the kpak line, daily care line, silk result line, and moisture recovery line.
 
Joico hands down. There isn't even any competition for me. I like the Redken cleansing cream for when I need to clarify/chelate and the butter treat is a decent leave-in, but nothing spectacular. I can't even remember what I felt about the smooth down.

I use both the K-PAK and Moisture Recovery Lines.
 
Last edited:
I've tried the Joico Moisture Recovery line and the Redken Real Control line, and Redken wins hands down. The Real Control shampoo is the only shampoo I've ever used that left my hair feeling like I had just conditioned. This is my staple line now.
 
I haven't used any Joico products yet but I don't think I'll be buying the Redken Smooth Down Butter...again. I need something that will not leave a residue on my hair if I re-apply day after day without clarifying or washing in between.
Someone from my job told me my hair was dirty! When I asked her to point out why she thought so, low and behold I saw flakes or some sort of residue on the surface of my hair (I was wearing a bun that week) as if I had applied some gel that dried up crispy in my hair. I need something that will penetrate, melt in my hair.

It smelled good and soften my hair but nothing that impressive.
 
Ooohhhh definitely redken and I am a fan of both. I really only use the intensive reconstructor from Joico because is the best of many that I have used. Redken has a lot of great products though. The All Soft line for redken is great and I love the smooth down line too. I've yet to try the new line directed towards us but I expect it to be as good as the rest of their products!
 
Joico has forever changed my life. I have liters of the K-pak and Moisture Recovery lines, but I prefer all the k-pak stuff. I am recently dabbling in the Redken Extreme line and I only have Rescue Force right now, but I like it. Not as much as Joico though.
 
Joico.

All the way.

Redken has some good stuff and can compete with Joico, unlike Nexxus in the other poll. (that was funny. :lol:)

But, over all I think Joico gives me more options. More of their products give me the softness and strength and elasticity.

I think I could use an entire line from Joico, vs. Redken with a few mix and match products from other lines.

Joico WINS! Again. :yep:
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

leona2025
Trial size products
Replies
10
Views
1K
leona2025
leona2025
T
  • Poll Poll
SALON PRODUCT FACE OFF: Nexxus vs. Joico
2 3
Replies
69
Views
27K
LABETT
L
davisbr88
Chelating Shampoo Ingredients?
Replies
5
Views
7K
krissyprissy
krissyprissy
JazziLady!
Ulta has liters on sale for $14.99
Replies
23
Views
5K
brooklyngal73
brooklyngal73
cherepikr
Joico, Rusk, Tigi, Brocato, Redken Liter SALE at Ulta
Replies
9
Views
4K
morehairplease
M
Back
Top