I agree with this as well. I have used the LOA in the past and things have worked out for me by using it, but God was always at the forefront of everything. I never got the impression that they were saying that you and only you control your life. The message I got was that by thinking positively it will influence you to make positive actions and essentially help things to work out in your favor.
I am able to do that because I look to God to help me make many of my choices while practicing the LOA.
LOA or Law of Attraction is a dangerous concept and even delusional.
One of the contibuters to the book A New Earth was asked on Larry King live, if LOA is real what about the 9 year old girl that was raped and murdered? Did she ask for it? He said we are what we attract. In other words , yes!
Are you kidding me?! What shameful wickedness!
Please, you cannot sit "wishin' and a hopin' " for something and it just come to you without you working for it. If God says you will be wealthy, you will have to be diligent in work for it to happen.
It sounds like that "name it and claim it" nonsense. Yet another preversion of Yahweh's truth.
No he didn't! This is tomfoolery. What is wrong with Oprah for entertaining this mess?
I've enjoyed reading the dialogue. Thanks so much for your thoughts. One thing that never sat right with me while reading a portion of The Secret was what to do about all of God's servants. When I think back on many prophets of the Old Testament like Jonah, Elijah, Jeremiah and on the people of faith listed in Hebrews, I know God was pleased with them because He says so in His Word. These people didn't fit the outcome of the Law of Attraction. They did not attract bad things to themselves (in fact in Hebrews it says the world was not worthy of them), they did not find easy parking spaces (I mean some of them were sawn in two!). No matter how positive they thought, God had plans for them and they did not include getting everything on their list because they believed.
But from my understanding of the LOA and The Secret, these people "attracted" bad things to them and they should have been more into their own will than God's then maybe they would have had an easier life because God would have been forced to abandon His plan for them to give them what they wanted instead.
These verses were also quoted somewhere on this thread and I think they are great so I'll quote them again. Unfortunately they are often taken out of context. Here they are in a little bit more of their context:
7"(F)Ask, and (G)it will be given to you; seek, and you will find; knock, and it will be opened to you.
8"For everyone who asks receives, and he who seeks finds, and to him who knocks it will be opened.
9"Or what man is there among you who, when his son asks for a loaf, will give him a stone?
10"Or if he asks for a fish, he will not give him a snake, will he?
11"If you then, being evil, know how to give good gifts to your children, (H)how much more will your Father who is in heaven give what is good to those who ask Him! 12"In everything, (I)therefore, treat people the same way you want them to treat you, for (J)this is the Law and the Prophets.
I bolded the end of verse 11. The Father gives us good gifts, but I am not convinced we all know what good gifts actually are. We may think they are a parking space, a raise, a new home, but unless they come from God they are not good. That parking space can put you in the way of a burglary or someone who has a ton of kids with them and who needs it more has to park far away, or perhaps that old person who parked across from you is going to bump your car. That raise can be spent on things you desire and keep your mind from focusing on God, or it can ruin the dynamics of your household (this happened when I was a child but I won't go into it now). That new home can be something other than what God wants for your life.
Unless you say, "your will be done" how does one know if it is a good gift?
I've enjoyed reading the dialogue. Thanks so much for your thoughts. One thing that never sat right with me while reading a portion of The Secret was what to do about all of God's servants. When I think back on many prophets of the Old Testament like Jonah, Elijah, Jeremiah and on the people of faith listed in Hebrews, I know God was pleased with them because He says so in His Word. These people didn't fit the outcome of the Law of Attraction. They did not attract bad things to themselves (in fact in Hebrews it says the world was not worthy of them), they did not find easy parking spaces (I mean some of them were sawn in two!). No matter how positive they thought, God had plans for them and they did not include getting everything on their list because they believed.
But from my understanding of the LOA and The Secret, these people "attracted" bad things to them and they should have been more into their own will than God's then maybe they would have had an easier life because God would have been forced to abandon His plan for them to give them what they wanted instead.
These verses were also quoted somewhere on this thread and I think they are great so I'll quote them again. Unfortunately they are often taken out of context. Here they are in a little bit more of their context:
7"(F)Ask, and (G)it will be given to you; seek, and you will find; knock, and it will be opened to you.
8"For everyone who asks receives, and he who seeks finds, and to him who knocks it will be opened.
9"Or what man is there among you who, when his son asks for a loaf, will give him a stone?
10"Or if he asks for a fish, he will not give him a snake, will he?
11"If you then, being evil, know how to give good gifts to your children, (H)how much more will your Father who is in heaven give what is good to those who ask Him! 12"In everything, (I)therefore, treat people the same way you want them to treat you, for (J)this is the Law and the Prophets.
I bolded the end of verse 11. The Father gives us good gifts, but I am not convinced we all know what good gifts actually are. We may think they are a parking space, a raise, a new home, but unless they come from God they are not good. That parking space can put you in the way of a burglary or someone who has a ton of kids with them and who needs it more has to park far away, or perhaps that old person who parked across from you is going to bump your car. That raise can be spent on things you desire and keep your mind from focusing on God, or it can ruin the dynamics of your household (this happened when I was a child but I won't go into it now). That new home can be something other than what God wants for your life.
Unless you say, "your will be done" how does one know if it is a good gift?
Operative term in your bolded statement: YOUR FATHER who is in Heaven....
Are people who are asking the Lord for these good things actually BELONG TO THE LORD? Who is the daddy? The Lord becomes "OUr Father, who art in Heaven" when we WILLINGLY give our life over to Him. Otherwise, the father one may be asking things from is the devil....
John 8:43-45 (Amplified)
43Why do you misunderstand what I say? It is because you are unable to hear what I am saying. [You cannot bear to listen to My message; your ears are shut to My teaching.]
44You are of your father, the devil, and it is your will to practice the lusts and gratify the desires [which are characteristic] of your father. He was a murderer from the beginning and does not stand in the truth, because there is no truth in him. When he speaks a falsehood, he speaks what is natural to him, for he is a liar [himself] and the father of lies and of all that is false.
45But because I speak the truth, you do not believe Me [do not trust ]Me, do not rely on Me, or adhere to Me].
I love your breakdown on this! I know even in my own life that I want things that are not in God's will for me. They seem to be good things but they are not good for me. I will gladly choose God's will over mine b/c He knows not only what I want but also what I need.
Operative term in your bolded statement: YOUR FATHER who is in Heaven....
Are people who are asking the Lord for these good things actually BELONG TO THE LORD? Who is the daddy? The Lord becomes "OUr Father, who art in Heaven" when we WILLINGLY give our life over to Him. Otherwise, the father one may be asking things from is the devil....
John 8:43-45 (Amplified)
43Why do you misunderstand what I say? It is because you are unable to hear what I am saying. [You cannot bear to listen to My message; your ears are shut to My teaching.]
44You are of your father, the devil, and it is your will to practice the lusts and gratify the desires [which are characteristic] of your father. He was a murderer from the beginning and does not stand in the truth, because there is no truth in him. When he speaks a falsehood, he speaks what is natural to him, for he is a liar [himself] and the father of lies and of all that is false.
45But because I speak the truth, you do not believe Me [do not trust ]Me, do not rely on Me, or adhere to Me].
God puts the thought/desire into your heart.mind. Without God's will I would not have thought, the desire, the plan to accomplish my/his/our goals. God is at the forefront of my thinking. God will make a way. He will define a path for me. However, I still have to put in the work hence the phrase "Pray and move your feet"I believe that my will and God's will is the same.
LOA is the move your feet part. - In my mind, you pray to God, he gives you instructions. If you are listening to him and following his word then things in your life begin to line you and you see the path HE has chosen for you by the people you meet, the signs you see on the street, the songs onthe radio etc..... and that is the arraction part. For me, there is no difference. If God truly directs your steps/thoughts/actions/feelings and you are focused on GOD and positivity...the "devil" should have no impact on your life.
LOA works every single time whether you believe it or not. Whether the outcome is good or bad, whether you are focus on GOD and his plan for you or you are indifferent to God's plan for you.
This is how I feel about it.
I can understand why some Christians would be turned off by it, because LOA focuses on how you can change your life if you change your thoughts, actions, etc. It does put more focus on yourself rather than looking to God to get your desires.
BUT almost everything they say in the book can be traced back to the Bible.
Have you read Joel Osteen's book, Your best life now.
Almost everything he says in that book are principles of LOA.
As a man thinketh so he is.
If ye have faith Nothing shall be impossible for you.
Life and death is in the power of the tongue.
There are others but those are a few examples.
I believe that they use the word Universe a lot in the book as marketing strategy, because everyone doesnt believe in God.
Why would I ask the universe for something when God who created the universe could give it to me? T
Well, in order to have a conversation it does help to know where/how people are defining such perspectives. And if a person is a Bible-believing Christian, then their "god" should have a name. There are lots of "gods" out there. Which one is being referred to?
Just like there are lots of fathers out there.... if I'm in a crowd with a lot of men who are fathers and I want my father, I have to call MY FATHER'S NAME SPECIFICALLY: (Jesse)....
I love your breakdown on this! I know even in my own life that I want things that are not in God's will for me. They seem to be good things but they are not good for me. I will gladly choose God's will over mine b/c He knows not only what I want but also what I need.
Growing up in a strict religious household (although I am not following it now),
the best way for me to understand much of the LOA / Secret thing and many other POV's as I've gotten older is to consider God as the Universe....if I look at God as infinitely expanding everywhere, then He would be the universe.
BTW, for me personally, it is not necessary to follow everything in a doctrine or philosophy, for example The Secret, to pull out the important "true" parts.
To me the most important thing is realizing what you are focusing on and if you are not happy change your focus. I am sure everyone knows negative people, whether they are Christian or not, who are always focusing on the negative and how bad things are...being around them makes you feel bad. So if a person focuses on what is good in their life, i.e. what God/The Universe has given them, it will only bring more goodness.
That's my interpretation.
How do we know it is God's will? Will you say well if you pray and mediate, you get the blessing than it is from God. It is similar principle to law of attraction.
For this cause alone, it is extremely dangerous and Christians --- serious Christians know better.This is how I feel about it.
I can understand why some Christians would be turned off by it, because LOA focuses on how you can change your life if you change your thoughts, actions, etc. It does put more focus on yourself rather than looking to God to get your desires.
BUT almost everything they say in the book can be traced back to the Bible.
Have you read Joel Osteen's book, Your best life now.
Almost everything he says in that book are principles of LOA.
As a man thinketh so he is.
If ye have faith Nothing shall be impossible for you.
Life and death is in the power of the tongue.
There are others but those are a few examples.
I believe that they use the word Universe a lot in the book as marketing strategy, because everyone doesnt believe in God.
For this cause alone, it is extremely dangerous and Christians --- serious Christians know better.
No man can serve two masters. It's one or the other. God has made it plain, that He will have no other God before Him.
The LOA isn't new. It's witchcraft; man exerting his will over God's will; or basically 'overriding God' to man's preferences/desires.
Don't justify it with Joel Osteen nor anyone else. If you've used it you were in sin and nothing short of it. You wanted something that God wasn't moving fast enough to do for you. It's just that simple.
Another thing.....Joel Osteen is NOT using the principles of LOA.... (Geesh! ) Stop giving the devil credit for what God has created.
The LOA fools and demons have plagerized God's Bibilical principles and have called them their own and have only given God credit when it's convenient for them profit wise.
From day one, when satan tried to place himself above God and failed, he has always taken what God has created and tried to make Himself the hero and the banner. And fools will follow him each and every time.
There is nothing in this life neither in this world that any of us can accomplish without God. Leave the witchcraft alone. Not once have I ever knelt and asked God for something, has He ever denied nor failed me.
The only thing He ever asked us to do was 'Believe".
Stay away from witchcraft! What price your life? What in this world could anyone possibly want from the hand of satan, when God has already given us all. This life and what's in it is our inheritance just for being a child of the most High God. We are His children and He will not deny us.
To those who are Christians who defend LOA, what in hell is it that you want, when all that you could ever need God is willing to give it to you and He has.
Stay away from witchcraft --------- self will.
Battlefield of the Mind by Joyce Meyers is an excellent read. It's LOA with a Biblical perspective. Everything is supported in the Bible.
LOA is not the 'devil.'. That is exactly the same as "For as he thinks in his heart, so it he." Proverbs 23:7. We can be Christian and follows God's word, but if we don't have the right mindset, then our blessings will be blocked.All it says is you get what you think
I'm Christian who is trying to reform my thought. I would pray to God and have faith, but still my life would be miserable because I didn't have any faith in myself.
As Christains, many of us are taught to "suffer." That's what I was taught at my church growing up. I learned that Christians should suffer, and if you are not suffering now, then be prepared, because you will suffer soon. So if things were going well in my life, I would self-satotage because that's what I thought God wanted for me.
But I was wrong, God wants us to be happy and prosper. His Will is to encourage us and to prosper us. So to me, the law of attraction is God's law. God can't prosper us if we are thinking negatively, or think that we don't deserve God's blessings.
But angel, why did it take this method of witchcraft to understand God, especially when you have the Holy Spirit of God who will lead and guide you into ALL truth.LOA has enhanded my understanding of how God works. It has allowed me to step out in faith and realize it's not about naming and claiming but about having faith and doing the work (physically, mentally, emotionally and spiritually). Most life enhancing concepts are met with opposition initially, LOA is no exception. Not everyone is going to get on the bus and that is okay, but when people are riding past you ......
LOA has enhanded my understanding of how God works. It has allowed me to step out in faith and realize it's not about naming and claiming but about having faith and doing the work (physically, mentally, emotionally and spiritually). Most life enhancing concepts are met with opposition initially, LOA is no exception. Not everyone is going to get on the bus and that is okay, but when people are riding past you ......