Oyin Handmade Burnt Sugar Pomade vs Jane Carter Nourish and Shine

[Evolving78]

i am running low on BSP and wanted to know if Nourish and Shine is similar? i really love BSP.. it seals very well and doesn't leave my hair dry.

 

[beautyaddict1913]

First lets compare the consistency - BSP is a lot creamier in texture than the JC - its easier to work with and the JC is just like shea butter - you really have to scoop some out and rub it around.
Next, smell. BSP smells a lot better. JC doesnt stink but its not a sweet or familiar smell.
Last results. BSP lays down my edges and I can seal with it and use it on my ends when they are feeling rough. JC does not do anything for my edges but it does promote shine and I can seal with it. BSP is a pomade and JC is a butter. JC is a lot more expensive but it lasts forever and u only need a little. I personally prefer BSP but it depends on what you need the product to do for you! In a nutshell, they are not similar!

 

[chrisanddonniesmommy]

I've only used BSP. So, I'm just going to keep pushing that, lol.

 

[Evolving78]

beautyaddict1913
very good review! i guess i will be sticking with my BSP! it is part of my Holy Grail, but i am running low. i think i have enough to last one more week, or less.

 

[tiffers]

First lets compare the consistency - BSP is a lot creamier in texture than the JC - its easier to work with and the JC is just like shea butter - you really have to scoop some out and rub it around.
Next, smell. BSP smells a lot better. JC doesnt stink but its not a sweet or familiar smell.
Last results. BSP lays down my edges and I can seal with it and use it on my ends when they are feeling rough. JC does not do anything for my edges but it does promote shine and I can seal with it. BSP is a pomade and JC is a butter. JC is a lot more expensive but it lasts forever and u only need a little. I personally prefer BSP but it depends on what you need the product to do for you! In a nutshell, they are not similar!

What she said.

 

[lilyofthenile]

First lets compare the consistency - BSP is a lot creamier in texture than the JC - its easier to work with and the JC is just like shea butter - you really have to scoop some out and rub it around.
Next, smell. BSP smells a lot better. JC doesnt stink but its not a sweet or familiar smell.
Last results. BSP lays down my edges and I can seal with it and use it on my ends when they are feeling rough. JC does not do anything for my edges but it does promote shine and I can seal with it. BSP is a pomade and JC is a butter. JC is a lot more expensive but it lasts forever and u only need a little. I personally prefer BSP but it depends on what you need the product to do for you! In a nutshell, they are not similar!

So informative, I may stick with BSP myself..

 

[Curlykutie]

I love my BSP like no other.