funny, I was looking for an answer to this also or more options. So far I'm enjoying Barry Fletcher's Twist like this. I did branch out and purchase afroveda's totally twisted ginger almond butter and it did not hold my twist through the wear and tear of a wig during day day (military) and my hair was more on the dry side. (could of been me) but the smell was wonderful. So I went back to Barry Fletcher's it's also called a puddy and I thought it was a perfect name for it. It holds my twist nicely and the twist seems to stay moist longer, but I wanted options as well.