Profectiv -- Different Jars, Same Product?

[DigitalRain]

Last night at Wally World, I looked at the ingredient list of all their products, at least the ones in the jar. Its seemed to me that all the ingredients are the same, give or take a few ingredients. I'm getting the feeling that most of these are pretty much the same product in different colors and jars. I use the Megagrowth and last night I bought the Anti Thinning Stimulant. I noticed they have the same smell and ingredient wise not very different at all. Anyone else noticed this?

 

[Karonica]

They did update their jars about a year ago, but it wasn't a drastic difference, not that I remember. It just said, "New and improved" or something like that. The product (Break-Free) was much creamier. I liked the new one.

 

[Supergirl]

I checked this out before. The ingredients do vary slightly between products. I thought that the Megagrowth (yellow cream) and Healthy Ends (pink cream) were the same. But there is that slight difference.

 

[deeplyrooted]

i feel you, DigitalRain.

from my perspective, i would only buy the mega moisturizing serum (pink, 4 oz., in a tall thin bottle) and maybe one of the jars/tubs of profectiv. their ingredients do seem rather similar, which is something i've noticed myself. EXCEPT, the mega moisturizer has flax seed oil extract and a few other great hair moisturizers that the tubs/jars don't have (at least that's what i've noticed from the few that i've

looked at).

speaking of profectiv; who's tried their shampoo??? does it have the sulfate stuff in it??? i saw it once in the store, but i was in too big a hurry to investigate.