</font><blockquote><font class="small">In reply to:</font><hr />
Mindymouse said:
There are many shampoo's that are natural w/o the sulfates you mentioned and are gentle for everyday use. To do "conditioner" washes imo is not beneficial. Shampoo is inteneded to Cleanse, Conditioner is to soften. So you are not cleaning you hair but adding polymers on top of polymers.
I don't know where the idea orginiated, but it really does'nt seem to be common sense or beneficial. Can somebody explain to me the benefits of it???
[/ QUOTE ]
Here is Lorraine Mastey's theory according to the curly girl book.
First the book is intended for women who wear their hair in it's naturally curly state. This is just important to mention because if you want to enhance your curls without having to use a ton of product the no shampoo routine provides this MAJOR benefit. So for type 4's like myself I've noticed my curls are more defined.
So the major thing in her book is keeping curly hair CURLY and doing so without all the frizz, having more well defined curls that are soft to the touch. Of course the frizz factor depends on the nature of your hair, if you are a 3 you'll have less frizz than say a 4 but it still works great for both.
My hair is definatly softer /images/graemlins/smile.gif and has more elasticity, which means less breakage for me, and more growth retained.
The second thing to keep in mind is that this book is also intended for daily washers it seems. I follow the CG routine because since I work out daily, I have to rinse/wash my hair every single day. I can't do that with shampoo, no matter how gentle it is. I've tried Mastey it left my hair hard. Jason's left me cracklin' dry, and Aubrey shampoo seem to leave my hair feeling rough and tangled. I've tried a multitude of other "moisturizing" shampoo's plus bottles of curl activator to come out with dry hair.
If you don't shampoo your hair daily, it probably makes more sense to use shampoo because you may have more product buildup than someone who washes daily.
The third thing about her theory is that friction + water gets the dirt out of your hair. It makes sense. If I scrubbed my body hard enough with just a wash cloth and rinsed, I'm sure I'd loosen the dead skin cells and remove dirt as well (don't worry, I use soap on my body LOL!)
She does mention that if you DO shampoo try to look for shampoo's without the harsh detergents OR to water the shampoo down.
The other thing she mentions is that most conditioners contain some type of cleansing agent in them (I forgot the name of one of them but I looked it up) anyway, which is why conditioners also "bubble up". I noticed that when I am scrubbing my scalp, sure enough my conditioner does provide a slight bubbly lather.
So far with this rountine my hair is not dirty, my scalp has no build up, my hair does not smell.....well, I take that back, it smells like conditioner but it doesn't stink.
The benefits for me have been:
1. No more brushfire waiting to happen on my head (from dry hair)
2. More defined coils, curls and waves
3. Softer and more moisturized hair
4. Less breakage and more elasticity
I don't use grease or any heavy styling products on my hair or scalp so this could be another reason why I don't experience build up.
As for build up with the conditioner, for my daily "wash" I don't use conditioners that contain a bunch of ingredients and I don't use conditioners that contain silicones, except on my deep conditioning days. So no problem with "over conditioning" so far. My hair isn't limp or anything.
Also since conditioners are temporary, by the next wash, it's out of the hair. I'm sure I'm not explaining that part correctly so if anyone else knows what I mean and can say it better...by all means /images/graemlins/laugh.gif /images/graemlins/laugh.gif The only thing that really bonds to hair is another protein, and even still you have to do protein conditioners every so often to refill the "missing pieces".
Anyway, this is the way I see it.... It's by far the CHEAPEST experiment I've ever tried. I mean I already HAD conditioner in the house, so there was nothing to run out and purchase. I decided that if I didn't like it, then the worse thing that could happen is (gasp!) I'd just have to shampoo.
But again, it works for ME, and works for ME may not be for everyone. Like shampoo for my hair leaves it looking dry, and hard until about the third day, but by then it's time for another shampoo.... but for others it works. The benefits for me have been listed above and I hope clarify why "I" do it. I can't speak to the benefits others have had.
So all in all, whateva works for YOU is what you should stick with.
Tara /images/graemlins/grin.gif